Premi in denaro alle Olimpiadi

5 Giu

Il 3 giugno sul sito della FIDE è apparsa una comunicazione relativa ai premi in denaro previsti per le prossimi Olimpiadi, che si disputeranno a Khanty-Mansiysk dal 20 settembre di quest’anno. Dal comunicato si evince che saranno disponibili sia premi di squadra che premi individuali:

The following prizes will be paid to the winning teams in the Open and Women’s events:

1st. – EUR 20.000

2nd. – EUR 12.000

3rd. – EUR 8.000

The three winning teams for the best composite scores in the Open and Women’s sections (The Nona Gaprindashvili International Trophy) shall receive:

1st. – EUR 10.000

2nd. – EUR 6.000

3rd . – EUR 4.000

Best Individual performance in both Open and Women’s sections (ALL Boards):

1st. – EUR 5.000

2nd. – EUR 3.000

3rd. – EUR 2.000

Special prizes for the best performance among new players in the Olympiad in Open and Women’s sections – EUR 2.000

[Only payable to participants that have not received another cash prize]”

Il 4 giugno sui più importanti siti scacchistici presenti sul web è comparsa una “open letter” a firma di Michal Krasenkov, in cui l’esperto GM polacco apprezza l’idea dei premi-squadra, così come apprezza la parità tra i premi dell’Assoluto e del Femminile. Ma considera una vera rovina l’istituzione di premi individuali. Quest’ultima potrebbe avere effetti devastanti sulla compattezza delle squadre, con conseguenze molto probabili come quelle di giocatori che si rifiutano di giocare le ultime partite per non inficiare la loro “performance”. Krasenkow porta a sostegno delle proprie considerazioni l’esperienza conseguita nella squadra polacca, quando il governo del suo paese aveva istituito premi legati alle prestazioni individuali per i giocatori impegnati nei confronti a squadre (a tal proposito Michal presenta i retroscena della disastrosa chiusura del Campionato Europeo a squadre 1999 da parte della squadra polacca).

Krasenkow invita la FIDE e gli organizzatori delle prossime Olimpiadi a riconsiderare la loro decisione, proponendo di eliminare i premi individuali e incrementare i premi per squadra; nel caso in cui questo non fosse possibile, perlomeno attribuire i premi inviduali per punti fatti e non per performance.

Michal Krasenkow

Il testo originale della “lettera aperta” di Krasenkow:

Open letter to FIDE and the organizers of the Khanty-Mansiysk Chess Olympiad

Dear chess friends,

The Chess Olympiad in Khanty-Mansiysk can be completely ruined. I think the organizers wanted to make an excellent thing funding money prizes for individual results but they probably didn’t quite catch the devastating effect on the team competition this move can bring.

I kindly ask FIDE and the organizers to urgently reconsider this decision. See the explanation and details in the following letter.

Board prizes at the Chess Olympiad.

I have just seen the news of the money prizes to be awarded for the best results at the Khanty-Mansiysk Chess Olympiad this year. The news is partly excellent but partly, alas, sad and devastating.

The team money prizes are the excellent part of the news. The best squads deserve to get rewards for their successful effort! And parity of men’s and women’s prizes is an absolutely just idea! However, as an experienced participant and occasional team captain at Chess Olympiads and European Team Championships, I am extremely concerned about the individual money prizes. They can ruin the performances of many strong teams and lead to pressure and conflicts within the squads.

For many years we had a similar situation in the Polish national team, when individual board medals were rewarded with government prizes and stipends. That led to the situation of players with good percentage scores (which guaranteed them medals) being not interested in playing in subsequent matches as they could just lose money! As they were the strongest points of the team, that led to tremendous problems. Even if the players were convinced or forced to play, they couldn’t play normally, usually lost and spoiled their individual and the team’s results.

The most spectacular story happened at the European Team Championship in 1999, when GM Robert Kempinski was going to win his board (and government stipend) with two rounds to go. But at the same moment our team was sharing the second place. Being the playing captain of the team, I convinced him to play. Both Kempinski (who played extremely nervously) and our team lost terribly in the penultimate round. Subsequently I had to withdraw Robert from the last round, saving the bronze board medal and the stipend for him but “sacrificing” our team result altogether (finally Poland ended up on the 17th place). With high money prizes for individual board results such situations will become typical for many teams!

Therefore I kindly ask FIDE and the organizers of the Olympiad to reconsider their decision. The best solution would be to cancel individual money prizes (including the rating performance prizes) and increase the number of team prizes.

If the organizers insist on rewarding individual results, then the sytem of awarding medals and prizes should be definitely changed, i.e. point scores, and not percentage scores, should be counted for the board rankings. That would encourage players to play more games and score more points. A similar system was successfully used in the Polish league. Although, taking into consideration the high value of the prizes, cheating and pre-arranged results can still be possible.

As for the performance rating prizes, I don’t see any way to eliminate their devastating effect on team results, and such prizes should be definitely cancelled. I am sure team captains and federation activists from many countries will back this appeal.

Kind regards,

Michal Krasenkow, grandmaster (Poland)

Annunci

Rispondi

Inserisci i tuoi dati qui sotto o clicca su un'icona per effettuare l'accesso:

Logo WordPress.com

Stai commentando usando il tuo account WordPress.com. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Foto Twitter

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Twitter. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Foto di Facebook

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Facebook. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Google+ photo

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Google+. Chiudi sessione / Modifica )

Connessione a %s...